ITSM ROI Calculator — Tideline Insights

Step 1 of 4 0%

Your Information

Let's start with a few basics.

Your information stays private. We use it to send your results and to follow up if you'd like our help.

First Name *

Last Name *

Work Email *

Company Name *

Job Title *

Please fill in all required fields (first name, last name, email, company, and title).

Your IT Environment

Tell us about your team and tooling.

This helps us benchmark your environment against similar organizations.

Full-time IT support staff (FTEs) *

Count staff who handle tickets, incidents, and day-to-day support.

Average annual salary *

Use fully-loaded cost if known. Not sure? Use $85,000.

Current ITSM Tool *

Industry Vertical *

Used to apply MetricNet vertical-specific benchmarks to your results.

Organization Size *

Affects incident volume benchmarks — larger teams have different per-FTE ticket norms.

How would you describe the quality of your operational data? *

This sets the width of your confidence interval. Better data = narrower, more actionable range.

Please fill in all required fields.

Incident Management

How do incidents flow through your team?

These numbers drive the largest share of ITSM cost. Be as precise as you can — even rough estimates produce meaningful results.

Average incidents or service tickets per month *

Check your ITSM dashboard or ticket queue for the last 90-day average.

Avg incident resolution time (MTTR) — business hours *

Your vertical benchmark: 8.40 hrs avg. Elite: under 2 hrs. (MetricNet, via HDI SupportWorld)

Incident Recurrence Rate *

Recurring incidents — same root cause reappearing — are a leading driver of cost.

Avg change failure recovery time — business hours *

Change failures typically take longer to recover than standard incidents. Industry average: 10–16 hrs. Not sure? Use 1.5× your incident MTTR.

Please fill in all required fields.

Change Enablement

How does your team manage changes?

Change failure is a top driver of unplanned incidents. Even a rough estimate here significantly sharpens your results.

Changes deployed per month *

Patches, releases, config changes — anything that touches your infrastructure.

Change failure rate % *

Not sure? Industry average is 15–25%. DORA 2024 defines elite as under 5%.

If you don't have a formal change process, enter your best estimate or leave at 20% — the industry average.

Almost there

Ready to see your full breakdown?

We'll send your results report to the address below. Ready to calculate?

Please complete all required fields above before viewing results.

Estimated Annual Cost of Poor ITSM

in recoverable operational cost per year

Estimated range: — (±30% confidence interval)

12-Month Goal

Achievable savings with structured ITSM improvements (25% reduction)

Elite State

Potential savings at industry-leading performance levels (40% reduction)

Business productivity impact not included — end-user downtime and ticket wait time are excluded from this estimate. Research suggests business-side impact typically adds 2–4× to the total cost shown above.

Three-State Cost Comparison

Metric	Current State	12-Month Goal	Elite State
Annual Incident Cost	—	—	—
Annual Change Failure Cost	—	—	—
Total Annual Cost	—	—	—
Annual Savings vs. Current	—	—	—

Scroll to see all columns

How You Compare to Industry Benchmarks

Avg Resolution Time (MTTR)

— Industry avg: 8.40 hrs (MetricNet/HDI)

—

Change Failure Rate

— Industry avg: 15–25%

—

Monthly Incident Volume

— Varies by team size

—

Loaded Hourly IT Cost

— Benchmark: $53–$70/hr

—

Let's Turn These Numbers into a Plan.

Book a free 30-minute discovery call. We'll walk through your results together and outline exactly what an engagement with Tideline Insights would look like for your organization.

Book a Free Discovery Call

About This Calculator This ROI calculator is a directional estimator designed to initiate a conversation with senior IT decision-makers — it is not a precision audit tool. The methodology is grounded in industry-standard ITSM research and is appropriately bounded by its listed exclusions. Results reflect reasonable estimates based on your inputs and published benchmarks; actual outcomes will vary by environment, tooling maturity, and implementation quality.

Estimates are based on industry benchmarks: incident MTTR average of 8.40 business hours sourced from Jeff Rumburg, MetricNet, published via HDI SupportWorld/ThinkHDI (Informa TechTarget); change failure rate benchmarks from DORA Accelerate State of DevOps Report (2024); improvement outcome ranges from Forrester Total Economic Impact studies for ITSM implementations (2019–2023). A 1.3× salary multiplier is applied for benefits and overhead, a standard HR accounting practice. Actual results vary by environment, tooling maturity, ticket complexity, and implementation quality. This calculator is intended to support internal planning conversations, not guarantee specific outcomes.

How We Calculate This

The calculator uses three inputs to estimate your annual cost of IT operational inefficiency. Every formula and benchmark is sourced from published industry research — no proprietary black box.

The Formulas

Loaded Hourly Rate = Annual Salary × 1.3 ÷ 2,080 hrs

Annual Incident Cost = Monthly Incidents × Avg Resolution Hrs × Rate × 12

Change Failure Cost = Monthly Changes × Failure Rate × Avg Resolution Hrs × Rate × 12

Total Annual Cost = Incident Cost + Change Failure Cost

Key Assumptions

1.3× salary multiplier — standard HR accounting for benefits, payroll taxes, and overhead. Adjust if your loaded cost is known.
Business hours, not clock hours — MTTR is measured in working hours, consistent with MetricNet's benchmarking methodology.
Single MTTR applied to both incident and change failure recovery — the same resolution time input is used for both cost components. In practice, change failure recovery often takes longer than incident resolution. This assumption is conservative and produces a floor estimate; organizations with high change failure rates should apply a multiplier manually.
IT staff cost only — the calculator measures labor cost of IT staff resolving incidents. Business user productivity loss during downtime is excluded. Research consistently shows business-side impact adds 2–4× to IT labor cost alone.
Conservative by design — outputs represent a floor, not a ceiling. Shadow IT costs, morale/turnover impact, and security incident costs are not modeled.

Benchmark Sources

Metric	Benchmark	Source
Average MTTR	8.40 business hours Range: 0.67 – 33.67 hrs	Jeff Rumburg, MetricNet HDI SupportWorld, 2018
Change Failure Rate	Elite: ~5% \| Avg: 15–25% Low performers: up to 40%	DORA State of DevOps Report 2024 Google Cloud / DORA Research Program Elite: <5% · Med: 15–25% · Low: up to 40%
FCR Rate	Industry avg: ~74% Top quartile: 80%+	MetricNet Global Benchmarking Database
Loaded Hourly Rate	$53–$70/hr typical range Based on $85K–$112K IT salaries × 1.3 multiplier ÷ 2,080 hrs	U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Employment Statistics (OES), Computer and Information Systems Managers; CompTIA IT Industry Outlook 2024. Midpoint $61.50/hr used in benchmark comparison.
ITSM ROI (3-year)	195% – 277% ROI Across ITSM implementations	Forrester Total Economic Impact Studies, 2019–2023
Improvement scenarios	25% (12-month goal) 40% (elite state)	Forrester TEI ITSM outcomes; conservative end of reported range
Vertical MTTR benchmarks	Healthcare 10.5 hrs · Financial 9.8 hrs · Manufacturing 8.4 hrs · Technology 6.5 hrs · Government 12.2 hrs · Retail 7.8 hrs	MetricNet Global Benchmarking Database; Jeff Rumburg, MetricNet. Vertical adjustments sourced from HDI SupportWorld annual benchmarking publications (2018–2024). Cross-industry baseline: 8.40 business hours.
Incident volume by team size	SMB ~40 tickets/FTE/mo · Mid-Market ~28 · Enterprise ~20	MetricNet Global Benchmarking Database; normalized per full-time support equivalent. Published via HDI SupportWorld technical support benchmarking reports.
Vertical CFR benchmarks	Technology 13% avg · Financial Services 20% avg · Healthcare 23% avg · Government 27% avg (vertical elite thresholds vary: 5–10%)	DORA State of DevOps Report 2024; MetricNet vertical analysis. Government and Healthcare benchmarks adjusted for regulatory change control requirements.

What This Doesn't Measure

The real cost of poor ITSM is larger than this calculator shows. These factors are excluded to keep inputs simple and outputs conservative:

Business user productivity loss during incidents and outages
Revenue impact of customer-facing downtime
Security incident and breach costs driven by change failures
Shadow IT and workaround costs when staff route around broken processes
Staff turnover and recruiting costs driven by firefighting culture

In practice, total ITSM cost of poor quality often runs 2–3× the labor cost estimate this tool produces.

Want to walk through your numbers with an ITIL Expert?

Book a Free 30-Minute Discovery Call

What Is IT InefficiencyActually Costing You?